7 Sarasota Fishing Trips That Earn Their Price

1.4-Hour Private Inshore Fishing Trip in Sarasota

★★★★★★★★★★4.5 · 19 reviews · 4 hours (approx.) Our pick

Captain James Gibson takes your private group of up to four onto Sarasota’s inshore waters for four hours of fishing. He supplies rods, tackle, bait help, and practical instruction while targeting snook, redfish, tarpon, and trout. Kids, dogs, and beginners are welcome, and the trip begins and ends at Harts Landing.

“Catching the fish. James knew exactly where to go on the bay to be successful. He was on time and had everything ready to go the moment we arrived.”

Check availability →Read our full review

2.Private 4 hr Fishing Tour with Master Captain Bill Phillips

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 8 reviews · 4 hours (approx.) · from $325Best value

Join Master Captain Bill Phillips and the Skyway Fishing Tours crew for a private fishing trip from Bahia Mar West Marina. The four-hour outing works Sarasota Bay inshore, while longer options reach Anna Maria Island and Gulf reefs. You may also spot dolphins or sea turtles along the way.

“Thank you for a fantastic time! We had a great time on our morning fishing trip and the caught a decent amount of fish”

Check availability →Read our full review

3.Sarasota Inshore Fishing Charters

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 3 reviews · 4 to 8 hours (approx.)

You’ll fish Sarasota Bay with a private local captain, often Captain Todd Walker, aboard a boat reserved for your group of up to three. Expect 4 to 8 hours on the water, with rods, safety gear, licenses, bottled water, and instruction included. Meet at 1059 N Tamiami Trail, where you’ll return after fishing the bay and nearby islets.

“Wow! Caption Todd Walker of Son of a fish charters was phenomenal! He goal was to get us on the fish and was kind, funny and respectful the whole trip! No worries foe female fishermen who are looking for a terrific local guide!! Highly recommended and we will be back!!”

Check availability →Read our full review

4.Half Day Private Fishing Trip with Site Seeing Around Anna Maria Island

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 2 reviews

Captain DJ takes your private group of up to three aboard a 20-foot center console from Bradenton Beach. Expect mostly bottom fishing, with chances to spot dolphins and manatees, snorkel, collect shells, and explore Egmont Key, Passage Keys, and nearby sandbars. Fuel, gear, water, and snacks are included.

“The visit to the Neolithic site of Capo Milazzese in Panarea is absolutely recommended for the charm it exudes: located on a rocky rise overlooking the blue sea of Panarea, the ancient village evokes the memory of a distant, prehistoric past, Read more”

Check availability →Read our full review

5.Inshore Fishing by Charter in Sarasota

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 2 reviews · 4 hours (approx.)

Join Captain James Gibson for a private four-hour inshore fishing charter from Hart’s Landing in Sarasota. Your group of up to two can fish for snook, redfish, trout, tarpon, grouper, flounder, and more, while keeping watch for dolphins and manatees. Prior fishing experience is helpful, but patient instruction is available.

“I booked this for my 14 year old son while he and I were on vacation. He is a bit on the quiet side but really loves to fish so although he was a bit nervous, he was still very excited.”

Check availability →Read our full review

6.Half Day Inshore and Nearshore Fishing Charter in Sarasota

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 2 reviews · 4 hours (approx.)

Join Captain Marc for a private four-hour fishing charter from Sarasota’s Sip N’ Slip Tours dock. Your group of up to four fishes inshore and nearshore waters for snook, redfish, trout, snapper, grouper, cobia, mackerel, and more, with chances to spot dolphins, manatees, turtles, and coastal birds.

“We had an amazing day fishing with Captain Marc in Sarasota! He was upbeat, patient, and clearly knows these waters inside and out. He put us right on the fish — we caught plenty of sea trout, redfish, and snook — and learned a lot along the way. Captain Marc made the whole trip fun and stress-free, whether we were casting, reeling, or just soaking up the scenery. If you’re looking for a great fishing experience in Sarasota, we highly recommend booking with him!”

Check availability →Read our full review

7.6 Hour Private Fishing Tour in Sarasota with Master Captain Bill

★★★★★★★★★★5.0 · 2 reviews · 6 hours (approx.) · from $425

Join Master Captain Bill for a private six-hour inshore fishing trip from Bradenton into Sarasota Bay. Your price includes licenses, fishing gear, bait, ice, and a guide. You may fish near Anna Maria Island’s Bean Point and the Sunshine Skyway Bridge, with time to learn, enjoy the views, and chase the day’s catch.

“Captain Bill provided an outstanding fishing experience. He has a nice newer boat with good equipment and great knowledge of the area. He knows where to go to catch fish. He is friendly and fun to hang out with on the water for a day. Highly recommended.”

Check availability →Read our full review